Shooting in RAW with the Fuji X10 Part2

I had a chance over the weekend to download the trial version of Lightroom 4.3 from Adobe's website. I'm looking at RAW Conversion software for the tricky X10 RAW files (Fuji call them RAF files), and had hit a brick wall with all of the options I personally owned (see last post).

Except for a very brief stint several years ago, I've never been a Lightroom user - choosing Aperture instead. Hindsight is a wonderful thing, and maybe Apple wasn't the way to go, but they were the first to come out with a 'Pro' RAW conversion application, and I was an early adopter. So I've stayed with them all the way through.

But now it seems that they have lagged too far behind, offering no RAW support for the X10 (and an apparently inferior RAW processing engine, depending on who you listen to)? So I downloaded Lightoom, to see if it offers better support for the X10.

Lightroom and Fuji RAF files - a beautiful thing.

The above image speaks volumes! Finally, RAW success. Good on you Adobe (sigh). If I want to shoot RAW with the Fuji X10, it looks like I will have to also invest in Adobe Lightroom as well. Probably money well spent, but I was hoping to avoid the extra expense if possible?

And then I had another thought. What if I converted the RAF files to the universal Adobe DNG RAW format and then imported the resulting DNG's into Aperture. Would that work?

Aperture lives to fight again - or does it?
Haha! Success again! Aperture will read the converted DNG files from the X10's RAW (RAF) ones, and then you have all the controls and adjustments available to you as if you were directly reading the out-of-camera RAW file.

The images looked good - but not great I have to say - so that also got me thinking... what kind of damage has been done to the file in the process? To find out, I processed the same RAW image in Aperture and Lightroom, and compared the resulting exported tiff.

Zooming in on a section from the Aperture file.
The first image is from Aperture. It has good colour, but the noise is fairly high (for an ISO 100 image), and the sharpness is also lacking. Overall ok, but it's not brilliant.

And the Lightroom version.
It may be difficult to tell on the internet (click on both to enlarge them for a more telling comparison), but I can assure you the Lightroom version taken directly from the Fuji RAF file is 'miles' better. Clearer, sharper, much less noise - the kind of image I would expect from the Fuji X10 (thankfully).

So final conclusion, as much as I don't want to admit it... - buy Lightroom :-) Darn it.

I have the trial version for another 28 days. In that time I will shoot some more RAW + Jpeg on the X10, to see if the Jpeg rendering makes shooting in RAW obsolete - and to look at the Jpeg comparison of Aperture and Lightroom straight out of the camera - to see if Aperture is worth persevering with, or whether I do, indeed, need to be switching camps. I have a sneaking suspicion I may know the answer to that already?  :-(

Comments

  1. UnknownDecember 15, 2013 at 6:09 AM

    Hi

    I have been playing with the x10 for some months now and also experienced problems with RAW convertion in software. I have not yet tried LR, but after reading several online post resolved to using the in-camera raw converter witsh produces superb resoults. Still it feels limiting to use the camera for this workflow. Have you doen any in-camera convertion and compered this to the resoults you get from LR?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

My X-E1 Film Simulation Recipe C2: Acros

Image
I'm seriously loving using the Fujifilm system - especially the custom film simulations. In this post I'd like to outline my C2 custom setting recipe - my version of Fuji Acros. Lake Mahinapua Jetty. Fuji X-E1. f/5.6 @ 1/350th, ISO 200. C2: "Acros" Jpeg Fuji Acros just happens to be my favourite black and white film. It's a beautiful, tonal, fine-grained film, that I shoot in my film cameras whenever I can. I was gutted when Fuji discontinued it in 2017, and then elated when they said they would be bringing it back in 2019! They have also introduced an Acros film simulation into their latest digital cameras - but only in the latest with the third generation processor. It doesn't look like it can, or will, be released in earlier camera models, since the Acros 'special sauce' requires the latest processor to work. Darn! So what is a guy to do? Hey, I know... why not make my own 'Acros' film simulation recipe? What a great idea! And s...
Read more

Making the move to Capture One

Image
If you have been around the Fujifilm ecosystem for any length of time, you will be well aware of the Lightroom vs Capture One for RAW processing debate. I've looked into this myself in the past here and decided that the dreaded Fuji 'worms' problem with RAF files wasn't so much a Fuji issue as it was an Adobe Lightroom issue. And therein lies the problem. Dorothy Falls , processed in Capture One Pro As an Adobe user myself, I have been loathed to change from Lightroom. I'm used to the UI, and until recently, I liked the results that I have been getting from Lightroom (more on that later). When I looked into the worm issue, I concluded that as long as you didn't oversharpen the files in Lightroom, then you would be fine. But, maybe I was wrong about that? Because recently I decided to test three cameras' image sensors against each other (see that post here ) - the full frame Sony a99, my APS-C Fujifilm X-E2, and an Olympus micro four thirds OM-D E-M5. Much t...
Read more

My Fujifilm X-E2 film recipes for Landscapes

Image
Now that I have gone through my seven custom film simulation recipes on my Fujifilm X-E2 (see previous blog posts), the final stage of the process is to do a comparison. This will help me decide which custom recipe I want to use, depending on the subject and feeling I'm after in my photo.  I think I have a pretty good idea anyway, but seeing them all together will help me confirm my suspicions. The first time I did this, I discovered that all my recipes were far too similar, and I decided to start over again from scratch. Hopefully this time will be different? Black and White film simulation comparison for landscapes. Fuji Acros v Ilford HP5 Since I mostly shoot landscapes, I thought I'd start there with my comparisons. The image itself isn't anything spectacular, and it's taken at the wrong time of the day - noon on a bright day. But this is also a fairly good test since the dynamic range is at the extremes of what the sensor can handle. The compressed images for the w...
Read more